Unidentified Anomalous Phenomena (UAP), also known as Unidentified Flying Objects (UFOs), have long captured the public’s fascination and speculation while stigmatized in scientific circles. The notion of extra terrestrial UFOs visiting Earth has been prevalent in popular culture for the better part of a century. However, the recently re-branded concept “Unidentified Flying Objects (UFOs) Or Unidentified Anomalous Phenomena (UAP)” emerged to represent an increasingly legitimate area of scientific interest and inquiry, relatively agnostic about the “extra terrestrial” hypothesis in pursuit of rational explanations. Current UFOs/UAP research encompasses a variety of scientific domains, meanwhile lacking in rigorous methods and sources of reliable data.
This shift in perception gained traction with a 2021 public report released by the U.S. Office of the Director of National Intelligence (ODNI). The report acknowledged that some incidents of strange objects in the sky remain unexplained and that more and better-quality data are needed to understand the nature of these objects, emphasizing a need for further investigation about Unidentified Flying Objects (UFOs) Or Unidentified Anomalous Phenomena (UAP). The report therefore sparked renewed scientific interest and public discourse and led to the formation of task forces, agencies, and initiatives to investigate Unidentified Flying Objects (UFOs) Or Unidentified Anomalous Phenomena (UAP).
One such task force, NASA’s Unidentified Anomalous Phenomena Independent Study Team (UAPIST), recently worked to identify existing data and to make recommendations for future data collection efforts to support scientific study of UFOs/UAP. The task force aimed to establish a roadmap for answering questions such as, “Are these objects real or are they sensor artifacts? Are they a threat to aerospace safety? Are they a threat to U.S. national security? Are they unknown natural phenomena? What else could they be?”. While the study team reports no conclusive evidence of an extra terrestrial origin for UFOs/UAP, it urges a continued role for NASA in U.S.-government efforts to study UFOs/UAP. Recommendations primarily focus on a critical need for destigmatizing the topic to encourage reporting and research, as well as high-quality, curated data adhering to the FAIR principles for Findability, Accessibility, Interoperability, and Reusability. Ultimately, the NASA’s Unidentified Anomalous Phenomena Independent Study Team (UAPIST) report and other recent developments emphasize that understanding Unidentified Flying Objects (UFOs) Or Unidentified Anomalous Phenomena (UAP) is a data curation and data science problem, with human and social science implications as well.
The broader search for evidence of life beyond Earth has catalyzed scientific progress in astronomy and related fields such as planetary science, exobiology, and the Search for Extra terrestrial Intelligence (SETI). However, scientific study of UFOs/UAP is subject to unique challenges and may be especially vulnerable to misinterpretation and sensationalism, indicating a timely need for strategic action among the iFields (i.e., information studies, broadly conceived, as defined in). This paper presents an exploratory study on existing research and opportunities for future work in UFOs/UAP Studies. A literature review was conducted targeting UFOs/UAP-related publications, with particular interest in scholarly discourse since 2021.
The study overall aims to begin bridging a gap between UFOs/UAP Studies as an evolving research area and Library & Information Science (LIS), along with other closely related and established perspectives including Science of Science, Sociology of Science and Technology, and research data management studies. This exploration of scholarly literature about UFOs/UAP aligns with the broader goals of these fields to understand how scientific knowledge evolves and gains legitimacy over time through consensus. The paper also aims to contribute to ongoing conversations surrounding the nature and study of UFOs/UAP, a previously stigmatized “fringe” topic that potentially represents an emerging interdisciplinary scientific field in need of novel information and data related research, support, and services.
The Harvard-based Galileo Project that is searching for evidence of alien technology. This research highlights motivations for studying UFOs/UAP along with a roadmap for deploying equipment and implementing multi sensor data processing pipelines, while the latter outlines computational techniques for detecting anomalous phenomena in data. A camera system design and software for calibrating the system to capture images of airborne objects for analysis of their movement patterns.
One of the researcher analyze a large dataset of Unidentified Flying Objects (UFOs) reports, finding reporting patterns with respect to time of day, as well as increased reporting activity surrounding media attention. Wu & Yang present a theoretical foundation for aircraft anti-gravity propulsion. One of the researcher speculates about the nature of extra terrestrial technology for interstellar probes, while Zuckerman(Researcher) challenges a current hypothesis that an interstellar object that recently passed through the solar system was alien technology.
In cultural studies, Fians(Researcher) points to a need for anthropologists to take “native” perspectives seriously to avoid further marginalizing groups including UFOs/UAP witnesses as Others. Marchena Sanabria(Researcher) shows how narratives such as UFOs/UAP reports were sensationalized by the media to distract from political corruption in Costa Rica between 1979 and 1985. Hayes [28] explores Cold War-era tensions between state actors and citizens surrounding UFOs/UAP theories and narratives. Wright (Researcher) takes a philosophical stance to examine the underexplored implications of alien and UFOs/UAP tourism for the tourism industry.
Social science approaches include Yingling (Researcher), large survey of faculty members showing that many academics think UFOs/UAP is an important topic for research. Stise(Researcher) analyze national survey data collected after the ODNI report release, showing an association between media use and belief in UFOs/UAP. Also following on the release of the ODNI report, Braum(Researcher) shows that people form favourable opinions towards conspiracy theories in general when reputable politicians acknowledge that UFOs/UAP may be extra terrestrial visitors. Adorjan & Kelly(Researcher) leverage UFOs-related “missing time” experiences to explore the importance and role of temporality in social constructionist scholarship. McVittie & McKinlay(Researcher) investigate the discourse of news presenters speaking about UFOs/UAP as they distance themselves from explaining the phenomena.
Religious studies scholars typically frame UFO and UAP as religious experiences. Agrama(Researcher) challenges the effectiveness of secular science in light of recent developments in the study of UFOs. Similarly, Zeller(Researcher) points to “enchanted” underpinnings of UFOs investigations despite their secular organizations and approaches. Kivari(Researcher) discusses how personal supernatural and paranormal experiences are integrated into broader social narratives. Finally, the Zeller(Researcher) series Handbook of UFO Religions tackles a number of topics ranging from specific cultural case studies to study of scholarship on UFOs and religion.
Within the humanities-classified sources, Hodges & Paxton-Fear(Researcher) analyze the writings that influenced Heaven’s Gate cult members as the texts evolved from recruitment to reinforcing belief. Rose (Researcher) explores racial aspects of Unidentified Flying Objects (UFOs) abduction narratives, suggesting that these stories may stem from a collective sense of white guilt regarding African enslavement and abduction accounts. Presenting a historical perspective, Guimont & Baumhammer(Researcher) describe a panel series that debated the role of pseudoscience in the history and public understanding of science. Rooted in philosophical schools of thought, Butman(Researcher) and Smith & Jonathan(Researcher) explore the epistemology and miraculous nature of UFOs respectively.
These results represent a snapshot of scholarly literature and discourse about UFOs/UAP at the time of this writing(September 2023). Researchers from diverse areas are approaching UFOs/UAP as a serious and actionable topic with implications for society and humanity (while stopping short of endorsing an extra-terrestrial hypothesis). Circumstances are likely to change and evolve quickly in the future, although it is presently uncertain whether UFOs/UAP Studies will develop into a recognized field. Nevertheless, credible research is underway and gaining publicity, suggesting a trend towards legitimizing UFOs/UAP Studies as an interdisciplinary research area. To uphold the recommendations of the recent ODNI and NASA reports, a need remains to shift the focus from viewing UFOs/UAP experiences as purely religious or psychological phenomena originating with the spirit or mind towards collecting standardized and reputable data across physical contexts and geographical locations, ranging from civilian and military reporting to high quality images and sensor data within and beyond Earth’s atmosphere.
Notably, nearly all research areas and publications outlined in the Results section align with some aspect of the iFields’ interdisciplinary research expertise, positioning these areas well for leadership in an emerging, multifaceted field of UFOs/UAP Studies, with the potential to support government initiatives and inform policy development and knowledge construction. As uncovered by Yingling(Researcher), academics are largely curious about this topic and consider it very important or essential to dispense with stigma and explore the nature of UFOs/UAP using scientific methods regardless of the eventual explanations for the phenomena.
As emphasized by NASA, Unidentified Anomalous Phenomena (UAP)-related data often lack standardization and may not be initially suited for analysis. Data curation and FAIR data practices are essential, particularly to support drawing conclusions from data collected across sources and contexts. iFields are well positioned to help ensure that appropriate infrastructures are in place while assisting various disciplines and research communities with developing strategies to make data FAIR and ensuring that data are compatible with tools for analysis. Furthermore, data curation experts can contribute to handling distributed sensor-generated data, assessing data quality, and supporting anomaly detection techniques to identify Unidentified Anomalous Phenomena (UAP)-related information that falls outside known constraints. Structured approaches to data management and information organization are crucial to ensure the integrity of a growing knowledge body of knowledge about UAP.
Understanding information behaviour and social dynamics surrounding Unidentified Anomalous Phenomena (UAP) is another key, opportune area for research. Especially considering that UAP is a historically stigmatized topic and has been long associated with conspiracy theories, human information behaviour and social informatics researchers can investigate how individuals seek, share, and evaluate information about UAP amidst a shifting narrative towards open curiosity and scientific study. Such research can shed light on the formation and evolution of online and offline communities and their impact on the dissemination of credible information about UAP as well as their belief systems. Additionally, studying various communities through a socio-technical lens can illuminate how they function and influence public perception, which is important for a comprehensive understanding of the phenomena and to support scientific investigation.
Data-driven approaches can be leveraged to make sense of Unidentified Flying Objects(UFO)/Unidentified Anomalous Phenomena (UAP). For example, Artificial Intelligence(AI) and Machine Learning(ML) techniques can be applied to analyze large amounts of data associated with UFOs/UAP to identify patterns, trends, and anomalies that might not be apparent through traditional methods. Machine learning models can be trained with various data types, including sensor readings, eyewitness testimonies, and historical legacy data and records. Natural language processing (NLP) techniques can also extract valuable information from textual sources such as government reports and historical documents. As emphasized in the NASA UAPIST report, key challenges for researching and understanding UFOs/UAP are data oriented.
iFields can also contribute by exploring how libraries and other knowledge institutions should effectively collect, curate, and make UFOs/UAP resources accessible to the public and researchers. This may include creating specialized collections, providing research assistance and reference support, and promoting critical thinking and information literacy skills related to UFOs/UAP as a topic of growing interest to the public.
The topic of UFOs/UAP is especially vulnerable to misinterpretation and sensationalism, perhaps in part because it touches upon the existential question of whether humans are alone in the universe. As UFOs/UAP Studies may become increasingly mainstream, ensuring communication of accurate and credible scientific information about the phenomena and in relation to previously established scientific movements such as the Search for Extra terrestrial Intelligence (SETI) is critical. iFields researchers can investigate various aspects of these challenges, including pinpointing sources and dissemination of misleading information as well as strategies for identifying and countering problematic narratives. This includes studying the role of media, online platforms, and information ecosystems in shaping public perception and belief systems surrounding UFOs/UAP.
The topic of UFOs/UAP may be an ideal entry point to engage the public in understanding and promoting data and science literacy. Educational programs and resources could be developed about UFOs/UAP Studies to enhance the public’s ability to critically assess and interpret data and scientific findings. This includes creating accessible materials that explain scientific methodologies and encourage evidence-based thinking, helping individuals to make informed judgments about UFOs/UAP claims and research.
In the context of UFOs/UAP, Science & Technology Studies researchers can explore the dynamics between scientific authorities, government agencies, and the public in defining and studying the phenomena. This includes analyzing the social construction of knowledge around UAP and how it intersects with government secrecy, military technology, international politics, and public perception. STS can also investigate the role of technological advancements in UFOs/UAP observations, such as the impact of sophisticated sensors and data collection tools on the data available for analysis. By placing UFOs/UAP within the broader framework of science and technology, it may be possible to develop a more comprehensive understanding of the cultural, political, and epistemological dimensions of UFOs/UAP Studies and the phenomena itself.
This article has presented a preliminary literature review and set of recommendations for involvement of iFields in UFOs/UAP Studies. The paper notes that LIS is underrepresented in the literature on this topic, indicating an opportunity to close a gap and apply demonstrated research strengths to understanding and explaining the societal, informational, and technological aspects of the phenomena. Future work by the author will build upon this initial exploration to address some of the iField research opportunities listed above and further analyze and expand a bibliometric dataset for in depth qualitative analysis over the past 50+ years.
The present study has some limitations, by virtue of its early-stage nature. Primarily, as the study intentionally prioritized recall over precision, many irrelevant results were returned, which presented challenges for manually reviewing all sources with close attention to detail. Also, the query may have overlooked some relevant sources by focusing only on acronyms (UFO, UAP) instead of full phrases such as “Unidentified Flying Object(s)” and “Unidentified Anomalous Phenomena” (though the acronyms are typically included alongside the full phrases). Future work will also further explore and adjust the search strategy to capture relevant sources to the extent possible.
UFOs/UAP Studies represents a rich and fascinating realm for further research and learning across the iFields. The NASA UAPIST report that inspired this paper concludes, “there is an intellectual continuum between extrasolar techno signatures, solar system SETI, and potential unknown alien technology operating in Earth’s atmosphere. If we recognize the plausibility of any of these, then we should recognize that all are at least plausible”. The first two (SETI and the search for alien techno signatures) are represented by small but established research communities and are supported by instruments such as the James Webb Space Telescope. As new communities, instruments and infrastructures take shape to support research and communication about UFOs/UAP, this “intellectual continuum” provides a natural home for information studies work.
Copyrights ©️
OBSERVERTIMES GLOBAL NEWSNETWORK PRIVATE LIMITED reserves the rights to all content contained within its official website https://observertimes.in /Online Magazine/ Publications
