REGIONALISM AND GLOBAL GOVERNANCE IN THE MULTIPOLAR ORDER: THE EUROPEAN UNION AND REGIONALISM IN MULTIPOLAR ORDER : PART III

The European Union(EU) has for long been a staunch supporter of regional cooperation and integration as a key element of global governance. On the one hand, the European Union(EU) has served as a primary reference point to a variety of region-building projects and has been regularly portrayed as an alternative to the model of economic regionalism promoted by the United States. On the other hand, the European Union(EU) has also sought to actively promote regional cooperation elsewhere as an essential part of its external policies. It has done so as a functional way of exporting stability and security and to encourage economic development and integration in the global economy. But by exporting its own model, the European Union(EU) has also sought to construct a distinct foreign policy identity of its own. As much as being a functional and pragmatic strategy, the promotion of regional integration has therefore also been “an European Union(EU) foreign policy objective that stems directly from its own internal identity”.

The European attempt to actively promote regional integration in third countries can be traced back to the 1969 Yaoundé Convention establishing the principle that regional organizations in ACP countries could benefit from Community aid and providing special tariff rates to groups of countries having signed the convention. In the decades that followed, European institutions further developed and streamlined the promotion of regional integration as part of their external policies. A Commission Communication in 1995 on “supporting regional economic integration” for the first time explicitly identified the accumulation of rules of origin (ROO), as well as Commission assistance with capacity building and institutional development as ways for the Community to promote regional integration. Other communications stressed the potential benefits to the European Union(EU) deriving from greater “south-south” integration in terms of market access and efficiency gains.

To operationalize these police objectives, the European Union(EU) has developed a series of regional strategies that determine the guidelines for European Union(EU) policies in certain regions. These strategies include funding envelops that usually appropriate some money to various issues connected to fostering regional cooperation – whether by encouraging political dialogue, trade cooperation or institution building. The European Union’s approach to promoting regional integration has also varied considerably according to the different political environments. On the whole, it seems possible to differentiate between three different approaches. In regions in which there is political support for regional integration, as in Latin America or Sub-Saharan Africa, the European Union(EU) has provided assistance to overcome capacity shortfalls and logistical bottlenecks to help with institution building. In regions where no political project exists, notably in Asia, the European Union(EU) has focused on functional cooperation and regular dialogue, as through the Asia Europe Meeting (ASEM). Finally, in its neighbourhood, the European Union(EU) has sought to actively build regional integration projects, as in the Mediterranean, which would not exist without its active support.

Some of these differences become apparent when systematically comparing the different regional strategies of the European Union(EU) on the basis of its Regional Strategy Papers RSP/RIP. These show a clear differentiation between the European Union’s emphasis on regional integration – in essence exporting the European Union’s own model – and the fostering of regional cooperation, as a more shallow way of fostering regional dialogue and cooperation. Especially in the latter case, engaging in inter-regional dialogues and other forms of inter regionalism has been an essential part of the European Union’s external policies.

Together, the European Union’s policies of fostering regionalism in third countries and exporting its own model of regional governance to others have been understood to be part of an European Union(EU)-specific approach to global governance. The essence of this approach is seen to be the promotion of a global order in which regional entities are the structuring units of international relations. Thus, according to Björn Hettne, the European Union(EU) seeks to foster a “horizontalized, institutionalized structure formed by organized regions, linked to each other through multidimensional partnership agreements”.

Indeed, this claim seems to have been verified by the European Union’s adoption of the concept of ‘effective multilateralism’ as the guiding principle for its approach to global governance issues. First introduced by the European Security Strategy of 2003, the European Union’s concept of effective multilateralism has sought to promote the development of a rule-based international order that is based on a closely interconnected set of international and regional organizations with a reinvigorated United Nations at its core. While the United Nations will remain at the core, a strengthening of region-to-region relations was regarded as essential to the strengthening of global governance. Javier Solana, the European Union’s former foreign policy chief, himself speculated that “in the years ahead these inter-regional dialogues will steadily shape the nature of international politics and forge new mechanisms to global interdependence and tackle cross-border problems.

However, with the emergence of a more multipolar world order, there is increasing evidence that the European Union’s approach to global governance is beginning to shift away from its former emphasis on the promotion of regional integration and inter-regional dialogue in its external relations. There seem to be several reasons encouraging this development.

First, the EU itself has gone through significant changes since the mid-2000s. As a result of successive enlargements and with the failure of the Constitutional project, there has been a shift towards greater inter govermentalism in certain areas of European Union(EU) governance. The establishment of the new European External Action Service (EEAS) is a case in point. No longer a purely supranational institution, the EEAS includes both national diplomats on rotation as well as Commission representatives. Given the previously noted connection between the internal identity of the EU and its foreign policy objectives, these institutional changes are likely to directly impact its global governance approach. This “re-nationalization of competences” can be observed in various areas of European Union(EU) policies and has been favoured by a lessening of support for a political Union amongst a number of member states, most importantly Germany.

On the other hand, the European Union’s aspirations to emerge as Europe’s voice in global governance have not received an easy ride in global governance institutions. Michael Emerson points out that Lisbon Treaty reforms interacting with the rules of procedure of the United Nations General Assembly (UNGA) could end downgrading the European Union’s presence. The reason for this lies in the fact that the Lisbon Treaty tasks the High Representative and the President of the European Council with representing the European Union(EU) in United Nations General Assembly debates. Prior the new treaty, this task was assigned to the European Union(EU) Member States representing the rotating Council Presidency. Because the European Union(EU) is not a member of the United Nations(UN), but merely one of the many observers, it can only make interventions in United Nations(UN) debates after all other 192 member states of the United Nations(UN). The European Union’s attempt to solve this problem and upgrade its representation to a level that is more equal to the United Nations(UN) member states in terms of speaking rights faced significant resistance in the United Nations(UN). The first European Union(EU) proposition was tabled in September 2010. After fierce diplomatic effort a compromise was found and it was passed in May 2011. One of the reasons for the initial set back was that the European Union(EU) would have gained a more prominent role in the United Nations General Assembly (UNGA) than other regional organizations. In return, European Union(EU) representatives have suggested that they would not oppose the upgrading of other regional bodies, if their integration reaches the level of the European Union(EU). Although not explicitly noted in this debate, the over-representation of European countries in global governance institutions have been criticized for quite some time. The European Union(EU) member states reluctance to give up votes and seats, have made it rather difficult to promote the European Union’s inclusion as this would further strengthen European influence. While the World Tread Organization(WTO) and Food AND Agriculture Organization(FAO) provide examples of how the European Union(EU) and its member states can work jointly when both are members of the organizations, these kind of arrangements appears to be increasingly difficult to achieve in an inter polar world.

Second, region-to-region cooperation and inter-regional dialogues have in general been disappointing in terms of their impact on global governance issues. One reason for this has been the structural weaknesses of the interregional institutions. Asymmetrical regional institutional capacities have tended to result in the adoption of the institutional characteristics and cooperation frameworks of the weaker partner (i.e. loose, informal and intergovernmental). On the one hand, this has made interregional summits into relatively insignificant events on the political calendar – the cancellation by the United States(US) of the biannual European Union(EU)-United States(US) summits in 2010 was a case in point. On the other hand, this has also meant that they provide a greater role for national governments, as in the ASEM format, in which European Union(EU) members states and institutions participate together. Rather than promoting the ‘European Union(EU)-model’, they therefore tend to entrench the ‘ASEAN-way’.

Finally, the ‘crisis of multilateralism’ and the growing importance of informal over formal means of international cooperation have unsurprisingly had an effect on European Union(EU) policies. Given the blockage of the formal multilateral institutions and a growing emphasis on bilateral relations especially with the new emerging powers, the European Union(EU) has felt that it had little choice but to follow suit. This has led to a proliferation of bilateral agreements and summits between the European Union(EU) and these new regional players in which fostering regional cooperation plays a diminished role. Similarly, while the European Union(EU) has been granted a seat at the table of the G20, it is the only regional organization playing a role in this constellation. In the light of these developments it remains unclear in how far the principle of ‘effective multilateralism’ still guides European Union(EU) external policies.

The impact on European Union(EU) policies has been twofold. First, while the European Union(EU) observed a de facto moratorium on bilateral trade agreements between 1999 and 2006 in order not to undermine the Doha round, since then it has engaged in a more active and commercially-oriented approach to free trade agreements. Second, the European Union’s attention has increasingly been drawn towards building bilateral strategic partnerships with a number of regional powers, including the famous BRICs and other emerging powers. While the European Union(EU) has argued that these partnerships are not contradicting its supporting for regional integration, there is ample evidence that strategic partnerships tend to emphasize the European Union’s economic and strategic interests, rather than promote longer term structural change in terms of an emerging inter regionalism.

Within the emerging multipolar order, the European Union’s policies towards regionalism therefore seem to be shifting. The recent shift in its own institutional balance and identity by necessity has been reflected in its foreign affairs. This is evident for example in its Mediterranean policies, where the role of the Commission has been replaced by that of single member states. This is also evident in its trade policies that have experienced a renewed drive for bilateral FTAs. Overall, the European Union’s policies therefore seem to have become more functional and interest-driven with less emphasis being placed on the explicit promotion of the European Union(EU)-model of problem solving and peaceful inter-state relations. Similarly, rather than favouring an “open regionalism”, there seems to be a turn towards bilateral agreements and a growing susceptibility towards the lure of a fortress Europe shadowing developments that have been taking place in other regions.

Copyrights ©️

OBSERVERTIMES GLOBAL NEWSNETWORK PRIVATE LIMITED reserves the rights to all content contained within its official website https://observertimes.in /Online Magazine/ Publications

Related posts

Leave a Comment