For the most part, concerns with food and agriculture after World War II focused on food shortages, growing populations, and regular famine. In response, scientists from India, Mexico, the Philippines, and the United States partnered with international organizations and foundations to create a system of cross-country research experiments focused on producing high-yield varieties of cereal grains to feed more people. This scientific collaboration created a system that could sustain further research in poorer countries in the future. Alongside the research collaborations, wealthier countries committed to transferring technologies like tractors, fertilizers, and pesticides for higher-yield crops to continue. Farmers were able to adopt the new high-yield varieties quickly, and food production was able to keep up with local population growth. Known as the “Green Revolution,” the production of high-yield grains, establishment of research centers in poorer countries, and technology transfer boosted average caloric intake in emerging regions as food prices declined, leading to better health outcomes and longer lives. The Green Revolution also ushered in the global mechanization and industrialization of food production, with effects for global health law.
As mechanization supported increased global trade in food throughout the 1950s, food additives in processed fruits, vegetables, and milk became significant areas of concern for individual and public health. Between 1971 and 2001, the growth in food imports was especially notable in low- and middle-income countries, which saw a rise of 115%, compared to wealthier countries at 45%. Food imports into all countries are increasingly processed; from 1991 to 2000, trade in processed food products accounted for some 66% of agricultural trade. Along with imports come risks for spoilage, adulteration, and contamination. “An estimated 600 million—almost 1 in 10 people in the world—fall ill after eating contaminated food and 420,000 die every year, resulting in the loss of 33 million healthy life years (DALYs).”
In the 1960s, globally accepted international standards were proposed as the solution to the food adulteration and contamination problems that accompanied trade in food. Those standards would, in theory, ensure that quality measures adopted in one country could be verified in a second or third country where the food was ultimately sold. The Codex Alimentarius Europaeus, a forerunner of the international regulatory framework that exists today, issued standards and guidelines for producers, regulators, and courts that achieved some of these aims in the European context. By 1963, the Food and Agricultural Organization of the United Nations, World Health Organization(WHO), and Codex Alimentarius Europeaus partnered to form the Codex Alimentarius Commission (Codex), with a goal of creating a global set of food safety, testing, labelling, and nutrition standards. Codex sets standards on food quality and safety, including food commodity standards and codes of hygienic or technological practice. “In addition, Codex evaluates pesticides, food additives and veterinary drugs, establishes limits for pesticide residues, and creates guidelines for contaminants.” There are now hundreds of standards, guidelines, and codes of conduct regulating the international food trade.
Although Codex’s standard development process is meant to “ensure fair practices in food trade” and “protect the health of consumers,” it has leaned toward the trade liberalization component of that mission. Codex has become an important channel for global health law as it becomes a more detailed, administrative body of law, not only with respect to its traditional standard-issue areas but also with respect to broader and steepening global health threats like antimicrobial resistance. Because Codex standards provide the benchmark against which food quality and safety measures are assessed when disputed under international-trade rules, the incorporation of health protections into Codex processes will become more important as “global health common law” develops through adjudicative bodies.
Though there were nascent efforts to address threats to animal health (the Office International des Epizooties (OIE) or Organization for Animal Health) as early as 1924, and for plants as early as 1929 (the International Convention for the Protection of Plants), global health law from its establishment in 1948 was primarily concerned with humans stripped from the environment —including plants and animals—in which they lived. As this anthropocentric model appeared to succeed, with more humans living longer and healthier, the result was expanded encroachment into the environment. This, in turn, caused significant changes to the nature and severity of threats to human health.
For example, one consequence of the Green Revolution’s success meant that land yielding greater quantities of cereals and grains could be rededicated to livestock production. Global livestock production has consequently exploded since the 1960s—“[b]eef production has more than doubled, while over the same time chicken meat production has increased by a factor of nearly 10, made up of increases in both number of animals and productivity.” In low- and middle- income countries, “[t]he share of the world’s poultry meat consumed … rose from 43 to 54 percent between 1990 and 2005 … . Further, the proportion of the world’s poultry meat produced in developing countries rose from 42 to 57 percent.” This production and consumption “will increase by 3.6 percent and 3.5 percent, respectively,” annually until at least 2030 “because of rising incomes, diversification of diets and expanding markets.”
More land dedicated to more livestock has resulted in increased interactions between humans and animals, both domesticated and wild. As those parts of the ecosystem interact, they give rise to increased channels for pathogens to migrate from wild animals to livestock to humans. The 2005 H5N1 avian-influenza outbreak produced a terrifying 50% fatality rate, primarily among humans who worked directly with infected birds. Although the precise origin remains unknown, the COVID-19 coronavirus is likely to have emerged from a live animal market or from agricultural animals.
Moreover, the overuse of antibiotics in the livestock-raising process has made even old pathogens more dangerous as bacteria develop resistance to inappropriately used antibiotics. Office International des Epizooties(OIE), FAO, and World Health Organization(WHO), as a result, have increasingly focused on global legal instruments to control these threats to human health.
In addition to poultry, much of this growth has revolved around pigs, another important host for human pathogens. “Pathogens” refer to bacteria, viruses, and other microorganisms that cause disease. The problems of new and re- emerging pathogens have arisen because of aforementioned shifts in human population growth, behaviour, and consumption. New or “emerging” pathogens are those that have newly appeared in a population or have been present but swiftly increase in incidence or geographic range. Recent examples include COVID- 19, HIV/AIDS and Lyme disease. Many of these pathogens emerge at convergence points between humans, livestock, and wildlife. Today, more than 50% of known pathogens infectious to humans are shared with animals (zoonotic diseases) and occur through recurring transmission or an initial spill over event. Worldwide, “more than 1 billion infections and 1 million deaths annually are attributable to zoonosis and vector-borne diseases.”
As the human population grows, more land is claimed for food production, and more interactions between humans and animals (including their parasites) result. For example, infected bats are important carriers of the Nipah virus, which is transmitted through contact with infected livestock or by eating fruit contaminated with bats’ urine or saliva. As those interactions multiply in the context of climate change and urbanization, both of which contribute to emergence and spread, conditions for outbreaks ripen. Indeed, annual population growth is exploding in areas that surround wildlife reserves, where these transmissions are likely to occur.
The ease with which humans cross the world means those outbreaks are more likely to become epidemics or pandemics than in previous decades. For most of history, human populations have been isolated from one another. Transcontinental exploration, the expansion of communication, and armed conflict have fundamentally changed these circumstances. The frequency, velocity, and volume of passengers by air, land, and sea transportation modes facilitate transfer of pathogens and vectors further, faster, and in significantly larger numbers than ever before. A person’s ability to reach almost any part of the world within the incubation period of disease with multiple stops and layovers means that travellers are important carrier risks for diseases. The increased transportation of bacteria through global travel and trade can turn what would have been a local outbreak into a pandemic.
The future of global health law is therefore necessarily the law of the human environment.
Linked to the problem of new and re-emerging pathogens and the growth in livestock agriculture worldwide is the overuse of antibiotics and the accompanying rise of antimicrobial resistance, one of the most serious and worsening threats to the fight against infectious disease. “Antimicrobial” agents or therapies kill or slow the spread of bacteria, viruses, or other microorganisms that may cause disease, or pathogens. “Antibiotics” specifically act against bacterial infections. Properly administered antibiotics kill illness-causing bacteria or limit bacteria’s ability to multiply, allowing the immune system to effectively respond.
“Antimicrobial resistance” describes traits and genetic elements, developed and then disbursed, by which infectious bacterial pathogens survive current antibiotic treatments and then pass on those traits. This development threatens not only the infected animal or human but also the broader community that now collectively faces pathogenic bacteria that are more difficult to fight.
Antimicrobial resistance renders current, relatively inexpensive medicines for treating infectious diseases “less effective or useless.” The decline in efficacy of these medicines endangers lives and raises the costs of medical treatment, because infections from resistant pathogens prolong illness, increase the likelihood of hospitalization (where hospitals are available), and enlarge financial losses attributable to inability to work and redirection of family care. “These drug-resistant bacteria, or ‘superbugs,’ present a serious and worsening threat to human health.”
Although there are multiple sources from which antibiotic-resistant bacteria may develop, “[f]arming practices are largely to blame for the rise of antibiotic- resistant strains.” Significant quantities of antibiotics have been used for promotion of growth and treatment of infections among farm animals and in aquaculture. Antibiotics are commonly used for routine, nontherapeutic application in food animal production to promote growth and to anticipate the effects of crowded and unhygienic conditions. Industrial farm animals release resistant bacteria in their feces, and resistant bacteria may be secreted into the environment through the animal’s feces or contaminated skin. When manure is applied to farmland as fertilizer, it may contaminate crops with antibiotic resistant bacteria. Water runoff from industrial farms can carry resistant bacteria and unmetabolized antibiotics into the water supply and, as a result, contaminate drinking water.
The World Health Organization has noted the public threat posed by excessive antibiotic use in animals, declaring that “widespread use of antimicrobials for disease control and growth promotion in animals has been paralleled by an increase in resistance in those bacteria . . . that can spread from animals, often through
food, to cause infections in humans.” World Health Organization(WHO) has advocated that the “[u]se of antimicrobial growth promoters … in humans and animals should be terminated or rapidly phased-out in the absence of risk-based evaluations.” Although scholars have advocated for the use of an Article 19 treaty to address antimicrobial resistance, to date World Health Organization(WHO) has only issued Article 23 recommendations, primarily because they “offer a nimbler, more adaptive option” in the current state of political sensitivities on the issue.
Copyrights ©️
OBSERVERTIMES GLOBAL NEWSNETWORK PRIVATE LIMITED reserves the rights to all content contained within its official website https://observertimes.in / Online Magazine / Publications
